This content highlights the importance of respectful discourse in nutrition science amid the polarized debates over dietary ideologies. It emphasizes the potential damage caused by public shaming of scientists and professionals who hold dissenting views, particularly in light of the Changing Markets Foundation’s report on alleged “mis-influencers.” The author shares a personal journey from veganism to a ketogenic diet, advocating for an empathetic understanding of diverse dietary perspectives. The discussion calls for a return to evidence-based dialogue, urging the scientific community to navigate ideological battles with care, compassion, and respect for all viewpoints in order to promote progress in nutrition and health.